THE REWARD MODEL FOR ACADEMIC WRITING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN THE AGE OF GENERATIVE AI: STUDENT EXPERIENCES AND TEACHER EVALUATIONS

TitleTHE REWARD MODEL FOR ACADEMIC WRITING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN THE AGE OF GENERATIVE AI: STUDENT EXPERIENCES AND TEACHER EVALUATIONS
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2026
AuthorsPartanen, R, Kallionpää, O
JournalProblems of Education in the 21st Century
Volume84
Issue5
Start Page802-818
PaginationContinuous
Date PublishedOctober / 2026
Type of ArticleOriginal article
ISSN1822-7864
Other NumbersE-ISSN 2538-7111
Keywordsacademic writing, AI, higher education, teacher education
Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) raises questions about how students demonstrate understanding through academic writing in higher education. This qualitative study provided a preliminary pedagogical evaluation of the REWARD model, which links reading, collaborative writing, application, peer-led activities, and discussion and reflection. The aim was to identify reported strengths, implementation difficulties, and priorities for development, including teachers’ perspectives on generative artificial intelligence (AI). Open-ended questionnaire responses were collected from 24 pre-service teachers who participated in a course implementation and five higher education teachers who evaluated a written and visual presentation of the model. Responses were analysed using inductive qualitative content analysis, and the findings were subsequently presented according to the model’s phases. Student responses described benefits from connecting literature, writing, and pedagogical application, alongside concerns about workload, unequal contributions, and uneven peer feedback. Teachers identified reading and writing as potentially vulnerable to AI-supported shortcuts and viewed application, presentation, and discussion as opportunities for students to demonstrate and explain their understanding. The evaluation concerns participants’ reported experiences and judgements; it does not establish effects on learning or academic writing performance.

URLhttps://oaji.net/articles/2026/457-1794479815.pdf
DOI10.33225/pec/26.84.802
Refereed DesignationRefereed
Full Text